Security Lab - Governance, Risk and Compliance Summary¶
Document Control:
Version: 2.0
Last Updated: April 2026
Owner: Paul Leone
Framework Versions: NIST CSF 2.0, CIS Controls v8.1, NIST SP 800-53 Rev 5, ISO 27001:2022, MITRE ATT&CK Enterprise v18.1, CISA ZTMM v2.0, NIST SP 800-207 Zero Trust, AICPA SOC 2 (TSC)
Executive Overview¶
Framework Alignment with Lab Mission¶
This cybersecurity lab demonstrates production-ready security capabilities aligned with nine industry-standard frameworks, each validating specific aspects of the lab's mission: enterprise-grade SecOps, Systems Engineering, Network Defense, and multi-cloud hybrid operations.
Mission Alignment by Framework¶
NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 validates threat detection & response capabilities across all six functions (Govern, Identify, Protect, Detect, Respond, Recover). Tier 3–4 maturity with automated incident response reducing MTTR to <30 minutes. Cloud integration strengthens IDENTIFY, PROTECT, and DETECT functions.
CIS Controls v8.1 validates defense-in-depth architecture through 93% IG1 and 81% IG2 compliance. Controls map to enterprise infrastructure operations with automated patch management across 5,000+ packages, comprehensive security monitoring, and cloud asset inventory integration.
ISO 27001:2022 validates security engineering & automation through 77% overall control coverage, with 91% technological controls. Policy-driven architecture with CIS Benchmark compliance, IaC automation, comprehensive audit capabilities, and A.5.23 (Cloud Services) fully implemented.
NIST SP 800-53 Rev 5 validates technical security engineering depth with strong implementation across Access Control (90%), Audit & Accountability (100%), and System Integrity (90%). Cloud controls integrated per family via Notes column additions in v2.0.
MITRE ATT&CK Enterprise v18.1 validates operational threat detection through 30% technique coverage (65/216 techniques) across 12 adversary tactics. Cloud containment actions integrated where applicable (T1562 Impair Defenses, T1537 Transfer Data to Cloud Account).
CISA Zero Trust Maturity Model v2.0 achieves Advanced maturity (Stage 3/4) across all 5 pillars and 3 cross-cutting capabilities. Cloud integration across all pillars; no change to overall maturity rating.
NIST SP 800-207 demonstrates implementation of all 7 Zero Trust tenets at Advanced maturity. Multi-cloud Use Case 2 (Cloud-to-Cloud) advanced from Medium to High applicability.
AICPA SOC 2 Trust Services Criteria (CC1-CC9) demonstrates Strong coverage (30/33 criteria implemented) with hybrid cloud scope (AWS, Azure, GCP) included from initial release.
Architectural Principles Demonstrated¶
Defense in Depth validated across all frameworks:
- Network perimeter: pfSense/OPNsense HA cluster, Palo Alto PA-VM NGFW (App-ID, Threat Prevention, User-ID), FortiGate 30D, Suricata/Snort IPS, SafeLine WAF
- Network visibility: Zeek NSM (protocol metadata, 3-segment coverage), ntopng/nProbe (NetFlow v9 from Cisco R1/R2/R3, 3560X, firewalls)
- Endpoint: Wazuh EDR 25+ on-premises endpoints + 6 cloud nodes (31+ total); CIS Benchmark SCA 92-98%
- Identity: Authentik SSO, Active Directory, Palo Alto User-ID AD integration, Step-CA PKI
- Cloud: AWS Security Groups, GCP VPC firewall policy (Google Threat Intelligence blocking), Azure NSG, Cloud Armor WAF/DDoS, GuardDuty/SCC/Defender for Cloud
Secure by Design validated through:
- Mandatory encryption: TLS 1.3, AES-256, IPSec IKEv2 AES-256-GCM/SHA-384, GlobalProtect TLS 1.3, Tailscale WireGuard (ChaCha20-Poly1305)
- Authenticated access: MFA (100% admin accounts), SSH key-based, certificate-based (Step-CA), Palo Alto AD-integrated admin auth
- Least privilege: Authentik RBAC, Palo Alto User-ID group-based policy, AD security groups, AWS IAM instance profiles, GCP minimal service accounts, Azure RBAC per resource group
- IaC automation: Terraform, Ansible, Git version control; cloud IaC via ARM templates and cloud Terraform modules
Zero Trust Architecture validated through:
- Identity verification: MFA enforcement, Palo Alto User-ID AD mapping, Authentik SSO 100% coverage; cloud console access enforces provider MFA; no passwords on cloud SSH nodes
- Network micro-segmentation: VLAN isolation, pfSense/OPNsense zone enforcement, Palo Alto security zones; cloud: AWS VPC, GCP VPC, Azure VNet each isolated; Tailscale ACL default-deny
- Encrypted communications: TLS 1.3, IPSec IKEv2, GlobalProtect, WireGuard; all cloud management traffic via Tailscale; no public management ports on any cloud node
- Assume-breach monitoring: Zeek protocol metadata, ntopng flow analysis, dual SIEM, 100% event logging; cloud: CloudTrail, GCP Audit Logs, Azure Activity Log, VPC flow logs
Multi-Cloud Hybrid Scope (v2.0)¶
| Provider | Nodes | OS | Native Security Services |
|---|---|---|---|
| AWS (us-east-2) | 2 | Amazon Linux 2, Windows Server 2025 | GuardDuty, Security Hub, CloudTrail, VPC Flow Logs, Inspector |
| Azure (North Central US) | 2 | Ubuntu 24.04 LTS, Windows Server 2025 | Defender for Cloud, Sentinel, Entra ID, DDoS Protection, Log Analytics |
| GCP (us-central1) | 2 | Debian 13.4, Ubuntu | Security Command Center, Cloud Armor, VPC Firewall Policy, Cloud Logging, Network IDS |
All 6 cloud nodes enrolled in on-premises management stack: Wazuh EDR (CIS SCA), PatchMon (Linux), WSUS (Windows), Checkmk, Ansible, Uptime Kuma. DNS resolves via on-premises Unbound (192.168.1.153/154) over Tailscale. No public management ports on any cloud instance.
Framework Purpose & Organizational Value¶
| Framework | Purpose | Organizational Value |
|---|---|---|
| NIST CSF 2.0 | Risk-based framework across six core functions (Govern, Identify, Protect, Detect, Respond, Recover). | Board-level reporting, vendor risk assessments, strategic planning, maturity benchmarking. |
| CIS Controls v8.1 | Prescriptive, prioritized safeguards in three Implementation Groups (IG1/IG2/IG3). | Security program development, gap analysis, resource allocation. IG1 addresses 80% of common attacks. |
| ISO 27001:2022 | ISMS requirements with 93 controls across organizational, people, physical, and technological domains. | Third-party certification, GDPR/HIPAA alignment, competitive differentiation. |
| NIST SP 800-53 Rev 5 | Comprehensive security/privacy controls across 20 families for federal and regulated systems. | FedRAMP, FISMA, authoritative technical baseline for government contractors. |
| MITRE ATT&CK v18.1 | Adversary TTPs based on real-world observations. 216 techniques / 475 sub-techniques. | Threat-based testing, detection engineering, SOC playbook development, purple team exercises. |
| CISA ZTMM v2.0 | Four maturity stages across 5 pillars + 3 cross-cutting capabilities for zero trust adoption. | EO 14028 compliance, modernization roadmaps, zero trust investment prioritization. |
| NIST SP 800-207 | Foundational principles and logical architecture for zero trust via seven core tenets. | Architecture design, RFP requirements, vendor solution validation against federal standards. |
| AICPA SOC 2 (TSC) | Security Common Criteria (CC1-CC9) evaluation for service organization controls. | Audit-readiness demonstration, service organization trust, customer assurance. |
Overall Lab Assessment¶
Operational Security Excellence
- 100% security event logging with dual SIEM (Splunk + Elastic) providing <5min MTTD
- Automated incident response via Shuffle SOAR achieving <30min MTTR with 15+ documented playbooks
- Multi-layered threat detection: Suricata/Snort/Palo Alto Threat Prevention IPS, Wazuh EDR (31+ endpoints), CrowdSec behavioral, Zeek protocol metadata, ntopng flow analysis, cloud-native ML (GuardDuty, SCC, Sentinel)
- Comprehensive vulnerability management: weekly OpenVAS + monthly Nessus, <72hr critical MTTR — enforced identically across on-premises and cloud nodes
Technical Architecture Maturity
- Defense-in-depth across network (VLAN + PA-VM zone segmentation, pfSense/OPNsense/Palo Alto firewalls, IDS/IPS), application (WAF, reverse proxy), endpoint (EDR, FIM), and identity (SSO, MFA, PKI) layers
- NSM sensor (Zeek + ntopng/nProbe): SOC-grade network visibility across Prod_LAN, Lab_LAN1, Lab_LAN2 — full protocol metadata + NetFlow v9 from all Cisco devices and firewalls
- IaC (Terraform, Ansible) with version control and audit trails; cloud IaC in same Git repository
- Advanced cryptography: TLS 1.3, AES-256, IPSec IKEv2 AES-256-GCM, ECDSA P-256, Ed25519 SSH keys, Step-CA PKI, WireGuard (ChaCha20-Poly1305)
- High availability: HA firewall cluster, dual SIEM, dual DNS <5s failover, redundant internet
Framework Compliance Summary¶
| Framework | Score / Maturity | Key Metric |
|---|---|---|
| NIST CSF 2.0 | Tier 3–4 (Repeatable → Adaptive) | 100% function coverage |
| CIS Controls v8.1 | 93% IG1 / 81% IG2 / 52% IG3 | 159 safeguards mapped |
| ISO 27001:2022 | 77% overall / 91% technological | 55 implemented, 14 partial |
| NIST SP 800-53 Rev 5 | 100% AU / 95% IA / 95% SC / 90% SI / 90% AC | 18 control families |
| CISA ZTMM v2.0 | Advanced (Stage 3/4) | 6 of 8 pillars at Advanced |
| NIST SP 800-207 | Advanced — all 7 ZT tenets | Use Case 2 (Multi-Cloud) advanced to High |
| MITRE ATT&CK v18.1 | 30% technique coverage | 65 of 216 techniques |
| AICPA SOC 2 (TSC) | Strong | 30/33 criteria implemented |
Infrastructure Updates (v1.2 → v2.0)¶
| Update | Components | GRC Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Palo Alto PA-VM NGFW | PAN-OS; App-ID; Threat Prevention; User-ID/AD; IPSec IKEv2; GlobalProtect VPN; security zone architecture | Advances PR, AC-17, SC-7/8, IA-2, CISA Networks/Identity, MITRE T1133/T1190 |
| NSM Sensor: Zeek | 3-worker AF_PACKET cluster; DNS/HTTP/SSL/SSH/SMB/RDP/DCE-RPC analyzers; Notice/Intel/Weird frameworks; JSON to Elastic + Brim/ZUI | Closes CISA Visibility gap; advances DE.CM-01, SI-4, CIS 13.1/13.2 |
| NSM Sensor: ntopng/nProbe | Dual nProbe (Cisco flows UDP/2055, FW flows UDP/2056); ntopng web UI port 3000 | Completes CIS 13.6 NetFlow; advances SI-4, AU-12, DE.CM-01 |
| Multi-Cloud (AWS/Azure/GCP) | 6 nodes via Tailscale WireGuard; Wazuh, PatchMon, Checkmk, Ansible across all providers; cloud-native security services | Extends all 9 frameworks to hybrid cloud scope; adds SA-9, SR-3, CM-8, A.5.23 cloud coverage |
| AICPA SOC 2 Added | CC1-CC9 Trust Services Criteria (Security Common Criteria) | New framework: 30/33 criteria implemented; strong CC5-CC8 coverage |
| Cisco/VLAN Enhancements | OSPF MD5 auth; 3560X DHCP snooping VLANs 10/20/30/100/120/200; uRPF on R3 | Strengthens SC-7, CIS 12.1/12.2, PR.IR-01, network segmentation evidence |
NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 Implementation Summary¶
Overall Maturity: Tier 3 (Repeatable) — Approaching Tier 4 (Adaptive)
Function Implementation Analysis¶
| Function | Tier | Implementation Summary | Cloud Extension |
|---|---|---|---|
| GOVERN (GV) | Tier 3 | CVSS-based risk prioritization; SLAs: Critical <72h, High <7d; policies version-controlled in Git; PAN-OS update lifecycle in supply chain controls. | Cloud policies: no public management ports, Tailscale-only access, CIS SCA via Wazuh, IAM least-privilege per provider. |
| IDENTIFY (ID) | Tier 4 | Automated asset discovery: 30+ hosts, 5,000+ packages (PatchMon), 50+ containers (WUD); MITRE ATT&CK mapping; MISP threat intelligence. | 6 cloud nodes tracked in Checkmk, Wazuh, PatchMon via Tailscale; cloud VPC/VNet topology documented; CloudTrail/GCP Audit/Azure Monitor for asset lifecycle. |
| PROTECT (PR) | Tier 4 | Authentik SSO/MFA; TLS 1.3/AES-256; PA-VM App-ID/User-ID/IPSec/GlobalProtect; Step-CA PKI; IaC (Terraform/Ansible); CIS Benchmark audits. | Wazuh CIS SCA on all 6 cloud nodes; PatchMon/WSUS patch management; Ansible hardening via Tailscale; no public ports on any cloud instance. |
| DETECT (DE) | Tier 3 | 100% network visibility; Zeek NSM (3 segments); ntopng/nProbe (NetFlow); PA-VM Threat Prevention; dual SIEM <5min MTTD. | GuardDuty ML-based detection; GCP SCC asset/vulnerability/IDS; Azure Sentinel KQL rules (NSG spikes, geo sign-in anomalies, AMA data gaps). |
| RESPOND (RS) | Tier 3 | 15+ TheHive playbooks; Shuffle SOAR; Cortex analysis; Wazuh Active Response; Zeek forensic metadata; PA-VM EDL for rapid IOC blocking. | Wazuh Active Response on cloud nodes via Tailscale; GuardDuty/Sentinel auto-create TheHive cases via Shuffle. |
| RECOVER (RC) | Tier 3 | AES-256 encrypted backups (bi-weekly PBS); snapshot rollback; HA DNS failover <5s; IaC rebuild <2hr RTO; documented RTO/RPO. | Cloud node rebuild via Ansible; RTO <2hr validated; Azure Spot eviction/restart documented; Uptime Kuma tunnel health monitoring. |
Key Achievements¶
- 100% Function Coverage: All six CSF 2.0 functions with documented processes and automated controls; now spanning on-premises and multi-cloud (AWS/Azure/GCP) scope
- Multi-Cloud EDR: Wazuh agents deployed on all 6 cloud nodes with CIS SCA policies matching on-premises baselines
- Zero Public Management Exposure: No public management ports on any cloud instance — all SSH/RDP via Tailscale WireGuard with device-bound authentication
- Cloud-Native Threat Detection: GuardDuty (ML, VPC flow/CloudTrail/DNS), GCP SCC (asset, vulnerability, network IDS), Azure Defender for Cloud + Sentinel (KQL rules) operating in parallel with on-premises SIEM/EDR
- Automated Response: Shuffle orchestration reduces MTTR by 70% vs manual workflows; Wazuh Active Response containment extended to cloud nodes via Tailscale
- Cloud Recovery Validated: Cloud node rebuild from Ansible playbooks tested; RTO <2hr achieved
CIS Critical Security Controls v8.1 Implementation Summary¶
93% IG1 / 81% IG2 / 52% IG3 compliance. 159 safeguards across 18 control families.
Implementation Group Compliance¶
IG1 (Basic Cyber Hygiene) — 93% Compliant
52 of 56 safeguards fully implemented. Complete coverage of foundational controls: asset inventory (1–2), data protection (3), patch management (7), centralized logging (8), malware defenses (10), backup/recovery (11). Gaps: application allowlisting (2.5), weekly unauthorized asset reviews (1.2), comprehensive data flow diagrams (3.8), formal secure configuration policy documentation (4.1).
IG2 (Enhanced Security) — 81% Compliant
60 of 74 additional safeguards implemented. Advanced monitoring exceeds requirements. Palo Alto App-ID/Threat Prevention advance Controls 12 and 13. Gaps: Network AAA (12.5), allowlisting (2.5–2.7), remote wipe (4.11), pen testing (18.1–18.2), RBAC documentation (6.8).
IG3 (Advanced Security) — 52% Compliant
15 of 29 additional safeguards implemented. Host-based IPS (Wazuh Active Response), network IPS (Suricata inline + PA Threat Prevention), WAF (SafeLine). Gaps: 802.1X NAC (13.9), DLP (3.13), mobile containerization (4.12), SAST/DAST (16.12).
Control-by-Control Analysis¶
| Control | Score | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 1: Asset Inventory | 99% | Cloud inventory integrated: 6 nodes in Checkmk, Wazuh, PatchMon, Tailscale admin console. |
| 2: Software Inventory | 70% | Allowlisting gaps remain. PatchMon extended to cloud nodes. |
| 3: Data Protection | 95% | IG1/IG2 complete. Cloud encryption: AWS S3 SSE, GCP disk/GCS, Azure Managed Disk + Log Analytics. |
| 4: Secure Configuration | 75% | PA-VM baseline added. Formal policy documentation needed. |
| 5: Account Management | 100% | Cloud IAM accounts integrated into lifecycle management. |
| 6: Access Control | 90% | Palo Alto User-ID strengthens identity-based access. RBAC documentation needed. |
| 7: Vulnerability Management | 100% | Exceeds all baselines. Cloud scanning: Wazuh SCA, Inspector, SCC, Defender for Cloud. |
| 8: Audit Log Management | 98% | Zeek JSON and ntopng flow data added. Cloud audit logs integrated. |
| 9: Email/Web Protection | 65% | Limited by homelab scope. DNS filtering extended to cloud nodes. |
| 10: Malware Defenses | 100% | ClamAV on Linux cloud nodes; Defender on Windows cloud nodes; GuardDuty/SCC/Defender behavioral detection. |
| 11: Data Recovery | 100% | Cloud node recovery runbooks documented and tested; RTO <2hr. |
| 12: Network Infrastructure | 88% | PA-VM zone architecture + IPSec/GlobalProtect improve 12.2/12.3/12.7. Lacks AAA (12.5). |
| 13: Network Monitoring | 93% | Zeek (13.1/13.2) + ntopng/nProbe (13.6) + PA-VM Threat Prevention (13.8). R2 NetFlow gap closed. Lacks 802.1X (13.9). |
| 16: Application Security | 60% | Infrastructure focus; custom dev minimal. SBOM planned Q2 2026. |
| 17: Incident Response | 85% | Shuffle SOAR + TheHive playbooks. Cloud node IR runbooks documented. |
| 18: Penetration Testing | 40% | Vulnerability scanning substitute; formal testing not conducted. |
ISO 27001:2022 Annex A Implementation Summary¶
77% overall coverage (55 implemented, 14 partial, 2 not implemented, 22 N/A). 91% applicable technological controls.
Control Domain Analysis¶
| Domain | Coverage | Key Highlights |
|---|---|---|
| 5. Organizational Controls (37 total) | 71% (22/31 applicable) | Threat intel (MISP/CrowdSec/GuardDuty/SCC/Sentinel); asset inventory 5,000+ packages; TLS 1.3 transfer (A.5.14); Authentik SSO (A.5.15); TheHive/Shuffle IR (A.5.24–28); Cloud IaaS security (A.5.23) fully implemented. |
| 6. People Controls (8 total) | 100% (2/2 applicable) | Remote working (A.6.7): Tailscale, GlobalProtect, MFA, TLS 1.3; security event reporting (A.6.8): Discord/email/TheHive + cloud alerting (SNS, GCP alerts, Azure Monitor action group). |
| 7. Physical Controls (14 total) | 33% (2/4 applicable) | Residential homelab constraints. Cloud physical security delegated to provider (AWS/GCP/Azure SOC 2 / ISO 27001 certified data centers). |
| 8. Technological Controls (34 total) | 91% (29/32 applicable) | Wazuh EDR 31+ endpoints; MFA 100% admin; multi-engine malware defense; weekly OpenVAS + monthly Nessus; PA-VM Threat Prevention (A.8.7/A.8.20); Zeek/ntopng NSM (A.8.16/A.8.20). |
Key Strengths: Technological excellence at 91%; enterprise-grade NSM; incident response maturity (15+ playbooks, SOAR orchestration); encryption everywhere (TLS 1.3, IPSec IKEv2, AES-256-GCM, Ed25519, DNSSEC); high availability.
Remaining Gaps: Formal DLP (A.8.12, planned Q2 2026), information labeling (A.5.13).
NIST SP 800-53 Rev 5 Implementation Summary¶
324+ requirements across 18 families. High maturity in technical families (AC, AU, IA, SC, SI) at 85%+ implementation.
Control Family Compliance¶
| Family | Score | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Access Control (AC) | 90% | 27/30 implemented. Authentik SSO/MFA, AD RBAC, session management. PA-VM User-ID (AC-3); GlobalProtect + IPSec (AC-17). Cloud: all SSH/RDP restricted to homelab subnets via provider-native firewall rules; Tailscale mandatory. |
| Audit & Accountability (AU) | 100% | 18/18 implemented. Dual SIEM, 100% event coverage, 90-day hot/1-year cold. Cloud: CloudTrail, GCP Admin Activity, Azure Activity Log forwarded to on-premises Splunk via Wazuh agents. |
| Assessment & Authorization (CA) | 80% | Weekly OpenVAS + monthly Nessus. Cloud: GuardDuty, SCC, Defender for Cloud as CA-7 continuous monitoring; cloud findings feed TheHive. |
| Configuration Management (CM) | 95% | Ansible/Terraform IaC, Git, CIS baselines, 5,000+ package inventory. Cloud: ARM templates and cloud Terraform modules in Git; Ansible applies CIS baselines to cloud nodes via Tailscale. |
| Contingency Planning (CP) | 75% | PBS bi-weekly encrypted backups, quarterly restore testing, HA DNS, <2hr IaC RTO. Cloud: cloud node rebuild tested; Azure Spot eviction/restart documented. |
| Identification & Auth (IA) | 95% | Step-CA two-tier PKI, Ed25519 SSH, Authentik OIDC, MFA. Cloud: SSH key-only for Linux cloud nodes; Windows cloud nodes domain-joined via Tailscale (Kerberos, AD CS). |
| Incident Response (IR) | 90% | TheHive 15+ playbooks, Shuffle SOAR, Cortex, Wazuh Active Response on all 31+ endpoints including cloud. |
| Risk Assessment (RA) | 85% | CVSS scoring, daily PatchMon, weekly OpenVAS, monthly Nessus, 75+ assets. Cloud: Inspector, SCC, Defender for Cloud supplement Wazuh scanning. |
| System & Comm Protection (SC) | 95% | TLS 1.3, Ed25519, AES-256-GCM, Step-CA PKI. SC-7 includes PA-VM App-ID + Threat Prevention + cloud boundary protection (Security Groups, VPC firewall policy, NSG, Cloud Armor, DDoS). |
| System & Info Integrity (SI) | 90% | Wazuh FIM/EDR, Suricata/Snort/PA-VM IPS, ClamAV/Defender, automated patching. SI-4 extended with Wazuh agent telemetry from all 6 cloud nodes. |
| Supply Chain (SR) | 40% | Vetted open-source, Docker SHA-256, secure deletion. Cloud: IAM least-privilege, minimal service accounts, ARM securestring params. |
MITRE ATT&CK Enterprise v18.1 Implementation Summary¶
Framework version: ATT&CK v18.1 (October 2025). Total techniques: 216. Total sub-techniques: 475. Lab coverage: 30% (65/216 techniques across 12 tactics).
Coverage decreased from 34% to 30% due to v18.1 adding 25 new techniques (13% denominator growth). T1537 upgraded MINIMAL to PARTIAL with cloud storage monitoring additions.
| Tactic | Coverage | Maturity | Key Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Initial Access (TA0001) | 67% (6/9) | Strong | Auth anomalies, VPN logging, WAF blocking, phishing workflow (Cortex + MISP), USB monitoring. |
| Execution (TA0002) | 67% (9/13) | Strong | Sysmon process creation, PowerShell script block logging, scheduled task monitoring, LOLBin detection. |
| Persistence (TA0003) | 37% (8/20) | Moderate | AD group changes (4728/4732/4756), Wazuh FIM startup/systemd, service creation monitoring. |
| Privilege Escalation (TA0004) | 38% (5/13) | Moderate | Admin logon correlation, GPO modification auditing (5136/5137/5141), sudo tracking. |
| Defense Evasion (TA0005) | 21% (13/46) | Weak | Immutable SIEM logs, registry tracking, security tool tamper detection. Cloud: CloudTrail alerts on GuardDuty disablement; GCP audit logs capture SCC changes; Azure Sentinel monitors Defender policy modifications. |
| Credential Access (TA0006) | 28% (4/15) | Weak | Brute force multi-source detection, LSASS monitoring (Sysmon EID 10). Cloud: GuardDuty CredentialAccess; Sentinel new-location sign-in detection. |
| Discovery (TA0007) | 32% (10/32) | Moderate | Suricata port scan/sweep/ARP; Zeek conn.log + ntopng improve T1046; AD LDAP auditing (4662). |
| Lateral Movement (TA0008) | 56% (5/9) | Strong | RDP (Suricata + EID 4624 type 10), SMB (5140/5145), SSH; Zeek rdp/smb/ssh logs. |
| Collection (TA0009) | 20% (4/18) | Weak | Archive detection, USB insertion (EID 2003), Wazuh FIM sensitive dirs. No DLP. |
| Exfiltration (TA0010) | 46% (4/9) | Moderate | C2 channel monitoring, MISP IOC, Zeek DNS/ntopng outbound. T1537: AWS S3 CloudTrail DataEvent logging, GCP Cloud Logging GCS access, Azure Monitor Storage account access (PARTIAL). |
| Command & Control (TA0011) | 42% (6/16) | Moderate | Suricata HTTP/HTTPS/DNS/SMTP, Unbound DGA detection, Zeek analyzers, PA-VM App-ID tunneling blocks. |
| Impact (TA0040) | 46% (6/13) | Moderate | Ransomware: Wazuh mass file modification + Shuffle workflow; cryptomining: Prometheus CPU/process detection. |
v18.1 critical new techniques requiring implementation: T1059.013 (Container CLI/API), T1678 (Delay Execution), T1679 (Selective Exclusion), T1036.012 (Browser Fingerprint Masquerading), T1562.013 (Network Device Firewall), T1546.018 (Python Startup Hooks), T1213.006 (Database Exfiltration).
CISA Zero Trust Maturity Model v2.0 Summary¶
Overall: Advanced (Stage 3/4). 87% of functions at Advanced or higher. Hybrid deployment: device agent/gateway (Authentik + Traefik), enclave gateway (pfSense/OPNsense/PA-VM), resource portal (Traefik).
| Pillar | Maturity | Cloud Extension | Next Steps |
|---|---|---|---|
| Identity | Advanced | Tailscale device-bound WireGuard key as phishing-resistant MFA equivalent; SSH key-only Linux nodes; domain Kerberos for Windows nodes via Tailscale; cloud IAM least-privilege; GuardDuty CredentialAccess; Sentinel geo sign-in anomaly. | WebAuthn/FIDO2 deployment |
| Devices | Advanced | Wazuh CIS SCA on 6 cloud nodes daily (Amazon Linux, Debian 12/13, Ubuntu 22.04/24.04, Win Server 2025); PatchMon 4 Linux; WSUS 2 Windows; ClamAV + Defender; cloud-native behavioral detection. | SBOM tracking Trivy/Grype Q2 2026 |
| Networks | Advanced | Cloud: Tailscale ACL default-deny; GCP Threat Intelligence blocking (TOR, malicious IPs, sanctioned countries); Cloud Armor WAF/DDoS; Azure DDoS Protection; cloud VPC flow logs to SIEM. | mTLS for service-to-service |
| Applications & Workloads | Advanced | Tailscale ACL gates cloud node access; GuardDuty, SCC, Sentinel auto-create TheHive cases via Shuffle; GCP Cloud Armor app-layer WAF; Azure DDoS; Ansible rebuild RTO <2hr. | CI/CD security scanning Q2 2026 |
| Data | Advanced | Cloud: AWS S3 SSE CloudTrail (90-day); GCP disk default encryption; Azure Managed Disk + Log Analytics encrypted; Tailscale WireGuard for cloud mgmt; Wazuh FIM 6 cloud nodes. | Formal DLP Q2 2026 |
| Visibility & Analytics | Advanced | CloudTrail, GCP Admin Activity/Data Access, Azure Activity Log; VPC/NSG flow logs to SIEM; Wazuh agents on 6 cloud nodes forward to Splunk; GuardDuty/SCC/Sentinel behavioral analytics. | ML/UEBA platform |
| Automation & Orchestration | Advanced | Wazuh Active Response on 6 cloud nodes via Tailscale; GuardDuty and Sentinel auto-create TheHive cases via Shuffle; Ansible cloud rebuild RTO <2hr; Terraform/ARM IaC. | Automated cloud network isolation |
| Governance | Advanced | Cloud policies version-controlled; AWS Security Hub, GCP SCC security health, Azure Defender Secure Score; cloud compliance visible in unified Wazuh dashboard. | Automated policy generation from threat intel |
NIST SP 800-207 Zero Trust Architecture Summary¶
Overall: Advanced maturity across all 7 ZT tenets. Deployment model: hybrid device agent/gateway (Authentik + Traefik), enclave gateway (pfSense/OPNsense/PA-VM/FortiGate), resource portal (Traefik). Trust algorithm: hybrid score-based and criteria-based with contextual evaluation.
| Tenet | Status | Cloud Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| 1. All resources explicitly defined | Advanced | 6 cloud nodes tracked in Checkmk, Wazuh, PatchMon, Tailscale admin console |
| 2. Communication secured regardless of location | Advanced | Tailscale WireGuard (ChaCha20-Poly1305) mandatory; no public management ports; default-deny cloud firewall policies |
| 3. Per-session least privilege access | Advanced | No passwords on cloud SSH nodes; Windows nodes require domain Kerberos; cloud IAM scoped per provider; no persistent elevated privileges |
| 4. Dynamic policy from observable state | Advanced | GuardDuty ML-based detection; GCP SCC threat findings; Azure Sentinel KQL rules; all cloud findings forwarded to on-premises SIEM |
| 5. Asset integrity monitoring | Advanced | Wazuh CIS SCA on all 6 cloud nodes daily; PatchMon CVE correlation; WSUS Windows cloud nodes; cloud-native scanning supplements Wazuh |
| 6. Dynamic authentication/authorization | Advanced | SSH key-only Linux; domain Kerberos Windows; cloud console enforces provider MFA; Tailscale device-bound key for all cloud access |
| 7. Comprehensive telemetry collection | Advanced | CloudTrail, GCP Admin Activity/Data Access, Azure Activity Log; VPC/NSG flow logs; Wazuh agents on 6 cloud nodes forward to Splunk; unified telemetry across on-premises and cloud |
Use Case 2 (Multi-Cloud) advanced from Medium to High applicability. Tailscale connects AWS (172.31.0.0/16), GCP (10.128.0.0/16), and Azure (10.130.0.0/16) into unified overlay with consistent policy enforcement.
AICPA SOC 2 Trust Services Criteria (CC1-CC9) Summary¶
Framework: Trust Services Criteria (Security / Common Criteria). Scope: On-premises + hybrid cloud (AWS, Azure, GCP, 6 nodes). Overall: Strong (30/33 criteria implemented).
| Category | Criteria | Assessment | Key Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| CC1: Control Environment | CC1.1-CC1.5 | Partial | Security-first policies in Git; quarterly GRC reviews; RBAC via Authentik/AD; immutable SIEM audit trails; Git commit attribution. Organizational governance limited by single-admin lab context. |
| CC2: Communication and Information | CC2.1-CC2.3 | Implemented | Multi-channel alerting (Discord, SMTP, TheHive); MISP bi-directional IOC sharing; Shuffle notification routing; cloud: AWS SNS, GCP alerting, Azure Monitor action group integrated. |
| CC3: Risk Assessment | CC3.1-CC3.4 | Implemented | CVSS base/temporal/environmental scoring; weekly OpenVAS + monthly Nessus; MISP threat feeds; Wazuh FIM detects unauthorized changes; cloud: CloudTrail, GCP Audit, Azure Activity Log. |
| CC4: Monitoring of Controls | CC4.1-CC4.2 | Implemented | Dual SIEM 100+ correlation rules <5min MTTD; Wazuh SCA CIS audits continuous on 31+ endpoints; Uptime Kuma 50+ monitors; TheHive tracks deficiencies with SLA enforcement. |
| CC5: Control Activities | CC5.1-CC5.3 | Implemented | 7-layer defense-in-depth; TLS 1.3 mandatory, SSH passwords disabled globally, MFA 100% admin, default-deny all platforms; controls deployed as IaC via Ansible/Terraform; extended to cloud nodes. |
| CC6: Logical and Physical Access | CC6.1-CC6.8 | Implemented | Authentik SSO + Traefik ForwardAuth; Ed25519 SSH key-only; PA-VM User-ID; Step-CA PKI; 30-min idle timeout; SafeLine WAF + Suricata IPS. Cloud: no public management ports; Tailscale device-bound access; provider-native firewall default-deny. |
| CC7: System Operations | CC7.1-CC7.5 | Implemented | Prometheus 15s scrape; Uptime Kuma 50+ monitors; Checkmk; Zeek NSM + ntopng; Wazuh SCA 92-98% CIS; Shuffle SOAR 15+ playbooks <30min MTTR; cloud node rebuild RTO <2hr validated. |
| CC8: Change Management | CC8.1 | Implemented | Git commit required for all IaC; Terraform plan review; Ansible dry-run; WSUS approval; snapshot-before-patch; branch protection + PR review. Cloud: ARM template and Terraform IaC in Git with same review workflow. |
| CC9: Risk Mitigation | CC9.1-CC9.2 | Partial | CVSS-based remediation; network segmentation; Wazuh Active Response; MISP proactive blocking. CC9.2 partial: no formal vendor contracts; SBOM (Trivy/Grype) planned Q2 2026. |
Strategic Roadmap¶
| Priority | Action | Framework Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Critical | Enable Kerberos event logging (EID 4768/4769) | MITRE T1558; NIST AU-2; CIS 8.5 |
| Critical | Implement pass-the-hash/ticket detection (EID 4624/4625 type 9) | MITRE T1550; NIST SI-4; CIS 13.6 |
| Critical | Enable comprehensive WMI logging | MITRE T1047; CIS 8.5 |
| High | Deploy Trivy/Grype SBOM tracking | NIST SR-3; CIS 2.5; OWASP A03; MITRE T1195 |
| High | Implement PA-VM NetFlow/IPFIX export to ntopng | CIS 13.6; SI-4; DE.CM-01 |
| High | Configure User-ID for Linux hosts (syslog-based mapping) | NIST AC-3; CIS 6.8; CISA Identity pillar |
| High | Deploy formal DLP solution | NIST MP-2; CIS 3.13; ISO A.8.12; MITRE T1048/T1537 |
| High | Azure Spot instance restart automation | Azure BC/DR; RC.HL-01; NIST CP-10 |
| Medium | Implement FIDO2/WebAuthn deployment | NIST IA-2(1); CISA Identity Optimal; CC6.1 |
| Medium | Deploy UEBA capabilities in SIEM | MITRE T1078/T1110; DE.AE-03; CIS 13.1 |
| Medium | Implement TLS inspection/JA3S fingerprinting | MITRE T1573; CIS 13.10; NIST SC-7 |
| Medium | Implement share enumeration monitoring (T1135) | MITRE T1135; CIS 8.5; NIST SI-4 |
| Low | Deploy firmware integrity checks (UEFI/BIOS monitoring) | MITRE T1495; NIST SI-7; CIS 10.5 |
| Low | Implement 802.1X port-level NAC | CIS 13.9 (IG3); NIST AC-3; CISA Networks Optimal |
Version History¶
| Version | Date | Description |
|---|---|---|
| 1.0 | January 2026 | Initial release covering six frameworks: NIST CSF 2.0, CIS Controls v8.1, ISO 27001:2022, NIST SP 800-53 Rev 5, CISA ZTMM v2.0, NIST SP 800-207. |
| 1.1 | January 2026 | Corrected N/A controls and coverage percentages across framework summaries. |
| 1.2 | March 2026 | Added Palo Alto PA-VM NGFW, NSM sensor (Zeek/ntopng), Cisco/VLAN enhancements. Updated PROTECT, DETECT, Zero Trust pillar evidence. |
| 2.0 | April 2026 | Added AICPA SOC 2 Trust Services Criteria (CC1-CC9). Integrated multi-cloud hybrid scope (AWS, Azure, GCP — 6 nodes via Tailscale). Updated all framework summaries. Consolidated executive overview. |